Article Artwork.jpg

While American citizens are prepping their Thanksgiving feasts, certain college students across the nation have made a conscious choice not to celebrate the holiday altogether.

Most people who attended conventional schooling as children were taught about the history of Thanksgiving through picture books with stories that depicted the first harvest between the Native Americans and the pilgrim settlers. The holiday is one that is deeply loved by most of the American public for its efforts to communicate a message rooted in the practice of giving thanks and practicing gratitude.

Though the holiday is cherished, many believe it’s also controversial, its true roots planted in Native American genocide. Years of brutal massacre of the indigenous people following the first harvest was neglected to be mentioned in students' early education, according to Native Hope. This has caused college students to think critically and question why Thanksgiving continues to be celebrated after learning about the significant history of oppression behind the holiday.

Just last year, students attending the University of Oregon hosted an event, “Thanks But No Thank-Giving," in efforts to highlight the history of the holiday by protesting it, according to the Daily Emerald. In late November of last year, a graduate association at the University of Pennsylvania hosted a freshmen dorm conversation which discussed how and why Thanksgiving is a racist holiday because it fails to acknowledge Native American people and their involvement in history. The event was intended for freshmen and also incorporated a critical discussion about American Politics.

Current senior communications major Emma De Soto, shares her views on the controversy, “When it comes to celebrating Thanksgiving I think for most people history doesn’t cross people’s minds. I personally understand why students are protesting against it — the history alone doesn’t make me want to honor the holiday, but the message of giving thanks is still something I admire and practice in my own family. I think approaching it differently as a country is an important step, but I’m not sure what that step would even look like.”

Along with Thanksgiving, there have been other holidays that have been brought into question on college campuses such as Columbus Day. LMU is one of the many universities that chooses not to celebrate Columbus Day. Instead, we have Autumn Day which occurs around the same time. In general, a greater effort has been made in recent years to have thought provoking conversations pertaining to the narratives attached to holidays and how it’s affected the country.

This is the opinion of Lucy Baker, a senior communication studies major from Sedona, Arizona. Tweet comments @LALoyolan or email

(3) comments


I think that some students do not consider Thanksgiving a holiday and simply consider this day to be quite ordinary and spend time on more important things, for example, on the learning process. You can write a well-written work on this day and check your work for plagiarism, you can use this free plagiarism checker at Paperell I think it will help to find flaws in your work and make it more unique.

Pat Rosen

'...and why Thanksgiving is a racist holiday because it fails to acknowledge Native American people and their involvement in history. '

This is patently absurd and untrue. Thanksgiving is a wholly unique holiday because it can be celebrated by anyone. People of any ethnicity, religion, background, political affiliation, anybody can celebrate Thanksgiving.

Also something else to consider, who are the people who complain about Thanksgiving? Coincidentally they're the same people who complain about anything nowadays, taking the bait that they live in a 'racist' and 'sexist' country and it's evil to its core. I feel bad for people who go through life thinking of America in those terms, truly I do. Such ingratitude for everyone who sacrificed all they had so you could parade around on your moral high horse while doing nothing to contribute to society. Sad.

Man with the Axe

There is way too little gratitude among the college-age population for living in the most prosperous and most free country in the history of the world, a prosperity and freedom that was purchased by the sacrifice of so many that came before. If they can't be bothered to give thanks because of some political axe they have to grind that doesn't speak very highly of them.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.